The short version: You usually can't do both. Signing a severance agreement almost always means releasing your right to sue, so the real choice is between money now and a claim that could be worth more, or less, years from now. Weigh the strength of your claim, what a lawsuit costs you in time and stress, and the deadlines. In many cases the best answer is neither extreme: use the claim as leverage to negotiate a better severance deal.
A severance offer often lands on the worst day of your working life. You're angry, you think the firing was wrong, and part of you wants to make the company answer for it in court. Another part of you wants the check. Both instincts make sense. The trick is to make the decision with facts instead of adrenaline.
Can I take the severance and still sue?
Generally, no. Severance is a trade. The company pays you, and in exchange you sign a release giving up claims against it, usually including claims you don't know about yet. (Our guide to what a Civil Code section 1542 waiver means explains how that "unknown claims" language works.) Once you sign a valid release and the deadline to revoke passes, the lawsuit you were thinking about is usually gone.
There are limits on what a release can take. An employer can't require you to release a claim for wages you're already owed (Lab. Code § 206.5(a)). A separation agreement can't bar you from disclosing information about unlawful acts in the workplace (Gov. Code § 12964.5(b)(1)(A)). But those limits don't let you keep the money and then sue over your firing.
Do I have to decide right away?
No. California requires an employer offering a separation agreement to tell you that you have the right to consult a lawyer and to give you at least five business days to do it (Gov. Code § 12964.5(b)(4)). If you're 40 or older and the agreement waives age claims, federal law usually gives you more time. See our guide to severance rights over 40.
Use that window to find out what your claim is actually worth. Don't sign out of panic, and don't refuse out of pride.
What makes a claim worth more than the offer?
Not every bad firing is an illegal one. California is an at-will state, which means an employer can usually fire you for a bad reason, or no reason, as long as it isn't an illegal reason. A claim gets stronger when the facts point to one of those illegal reasons:
- Discrimination based on a protected characteristic, such as age (40 and over), disability, pregnancy, race, or sex.
- Retaliation after you complained about harassment or discrimination, reported something illegal, or raised a wage or safety issue.
- Leave or accommodation problems, like being fired soon after medical leave, pregnancy leave, or a request for an accommodation.
- Unpaid money the company already owes you, such as wages, commissions, or earned bonuses.
Evidence matters more than outrage. Emails, texts, performance reviews that suddenly turned negative, a short gap between your complaint and your firing, and coworkers who saw what happened all change the math. If your claim rests mostly on "my boss didn't like me," the severance check may be the better deal.
What could I win if I sued?
For a claim under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act, the Civil Rights Department lists remedies that can include back pay, front pay, out-of-pocket expenses, damages for emotional distress, punitive damages, and attorney's fees and costs.
The fee rule is a big deal for workers. A court may award reasonable attorney's fees to the winning side, but a winning employer can't get its fees unless the court finds your case was frivolous, unreasonable, or groundless when you brought it, or that you kept litigating after it clearly became so (Gov. Code § 12965(c)(6)). In other words, losing a good-faith case doesn't usually mean paying the company's lawyers.
No one can promise you a result. A claim that looks strong on day one can get weaker once the company produces its own documents.
What does suing actually cost me?
Money isn't the only cost. Think honestly about these:
- Time. A lawsuit can take years. Severance is money now, when you may need it most.
- Stress. You'll relive the worst parts of your job in writing, in a deposition, and maybe in a courtroom.
- Uncertainty. A judge or jury can disagree with you. Severance is guaranteed once the deal is signed.
- Privacy. Lawsuits are public. Severance deals usually aren't.
None of that means you shouldn't sue. It means the dollar figure a lawsuit might bring has to be weighed against what it takes to get there.
What are the deadlines if I don't sign?
For most discrimination and retaliation claims under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act, you must file with the Civil Rights Department before you can go to court. The Department says you must submit your intake form within three years of the date you were last harmed, and that you can request an immediate right-to-sue notice when you file. After you receive that notice, you generally have one year from its date to file your lawsuit (Gov. Code § 12965(c)(1)(D)).
Other claims have different clocks, and some are shorter. Get the deadlines for your specific claims checked early, because a missed deadline can end a claim no matter how strong it is.
Is there a middle path?
Usually, yes, and it's the one most people end up taking. The same facts that would support a lawsuit are what give you leverage in a severance negotiation. A company that would rather not defend a retaliation claim may pay a lot more than its first offer to get your signature. Our guide on how much severance to ask for walks through how that leverage turns into a number.
Negotiating has risk too. An employer can withdraw an offer. But a counteroffer backed by real facts often lands somewhere between the company's spreadsheet number and what a lawsuit might bring, without the years of waiting.
The takeaway
Don't treat this as a gut call. Write down what happened before you were let go, in order, with dates. Pull together your offer letter, reviews, and any emails or texts that back you up. Then get your claim assessed before your deadline to sign runs out. Whether you take the deal, push for a better one, or walk away to sue, you'll be choosing with your eyes open.
Have a severance offer on the table?
Talk to us before you sign. Tell us what happened, and we'll help you figure out whether there's room to negotiate.
Get help nowThis article is general information about California and federal law as of its date, not legal advice for your situation. Laws change, and the right move depends on your facts.