The short version: Yes, you can still negotiate. A severance offer after a performance termination is a trade: the company pays, and you release your legal claims. The "performance" label doesn't remove those claims, and it often hides them. Before you sign, get your personnel file, look at what happened before you were let go, and use the time California law gives you to review the agreement.
Getting fired for performance stings. It also makes a lot of people assume they have no bargaining power. If HR says you weren't meeting expectations, why would anyone owe you more?
Because the company already decided to pay you something. That tells you it wants your signature.
What is the company buying?
A severance agreement almost always includes a release, your promise not to sue over your job or your exit. California's Civil Rights Department confirms that an employer may include a general release or waiver of claims in a separation agreement, as long as the release is otherwise lawful and valid (Gov. Code § 12964.5(b), per the CRD's guidance on separation agreements).
So the real question is what that release is worth. If you have no claims at all, the company is paying for peace of mind and little else. If you have even one credible claim, your signature is worth more.
Does a "performance" reason protect the company?
Not automatically. A company can call a termination "performance" and still have a different reason underneath. Look for these patterns:
- Timing. Your reviews were fine until you complained about pay, safety, harassment, or a manager, or until you asked for a leave or an accommodation.
- A thin paper trail. No written warnings or a performance plan that appeared only after something changed.
- Uneven treatment. Coworkers with the same numbers or issues were not let go.
California's Civil Rights Department handles complaints of discrimination, harassment, and retaliation at work, and says firing someone for filing a CRD complaint is illegal retaliation (CRD complaint process). The Labor Commissioner's Office handles retaliation for things like workplace health or safety complaints and for speaking to the Labor Commissioner about working conditions (DLSE retaliation complaints). Discrimination based on race, sex, disability, national origin, and other protected characteristics goes to the CRD.
None of this means you have a winning case. It means the company has to weigh the risk that you do, and that weighing is where your leverage comes from. For more on how leverage turns into a number, read how much severance to ask for.
What deadlines matter?
- Review time. An employer offering a separation agreement must tell you that you can consult an attorney and give you at least five business days to do so. The CRD says an employer can't require you to sign it the day it's offered (Gov. Code § 12964.5(b)). If you're 40 or older, federal law adds more time.
- Claim deadlines. For discrimination, harassment, or retaliation covered by the CRD, you generally must submit an intake form within three years of the date you were last harmed, and you need a right-to-sue notice from the CRD before filing your own lawsuit (CRD complaint process). The Labor Commissioner's page lists one year from the retaliatory act for general retaliation complaints, with shorter deadlines for some claims (DLSE). Signing a release can end these claims, so don't let a deadline on the offer push you past the time you need to evaluate them.
What do I get regardless of what I sign?
Your final paycheck is separate from severance. A discharged employee must be paid all wages, including accrued vacation, immediately at termination (Lab. Code §§ 201, 227.3). If the employer willfully fails to pay, the penalty can run up to 30 days of wages (Lab. Code § 203). The Labor Commissioner's office also says that an employer must pay whatever wages are due and not in dispute without requiring a release (Lab. Code § 206) (DLSE final pay guidance). Don't let anyone treat money you've already earned as a bargaining chip.
Can I still collect unemployment?
Often, yes. In California, being fired is not the same as being fired for misconduct. EDD's guidance says that not every employee discharged for unsatisfactory performance is discharged for misconduct. Under the regulation EDD applies (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 22, § 1256-38), misconduct requires something like an intentional failure to perform, gross negligence, or repeated negligent performance after a warning when you were able to perform. "Ordinarily inability or incapacity to perform the job or inefficient performance is not misconduct" (EDD Misconduct MC 300).
That matters in negotiation. How the company describes your termination can affect your claim, so ask that the agreement and any reference describe it neutrally. The EDD makes its own decision either way.
What should I do first?
- Don't sign yet. Use the review time.
- Request your personnel file in writing. Current and former employees can inspect and get copies of personnel records, and the employer must respond within 30 calendar days of a written request. A former employee can make this request once a year, and an employer that fails to comply can owe a $750 penalty (Lab. Code § 1198.5) (DLSE personnel files FAQ). Do it right away, since 30 days can outlast your offer.
- Write a timeline. Dates of your reviews, warnings, complaints, requests for leave, and the day things changed.
- Save what you lawfully have. Your offer letter, reviews, and the termination notice.
- Look past the dollar figure. Health coverage, a neutral reference, how your exit is described, and bonuses or commissions are all on the table.
The takeaway
A performance termination is the company's version of events, and a severance offer is the company's first number. Neither is final. Get your file, write down the timeline, and find out what your release is worth before you sign. If you'd like an attorney to look at your offer, use the intake form.
Have a severance offer on the table?
Talk to us before you sign. Tell us what happened, and we'll help you figure out whether there's room to negotiate.
Get help nowThis article is general information about California and federal law as of its date, not legal advice for your situation. Laws change, and the right move depends on your facts.